GIS vs. CurbIQ: What Are the Differences?
Proactive management of curbside space is one of the best things cities can do to improve urban mobility for all modes of transportation. We’ve written about this before and shown how quick and easy it can be for a city to get started by digitizing their existing curbside regulations. But once you’ve done that, what’s next? How can you best summarize this information to gain insights on how curbside restrictions change over time, sort out whether the existing allocation meets your needs, and make changes where existing rules don’t align with local priorities?
Since the resulting curb layer is geospatially referenced, you may be tempted to crack open your favourite GIS application and take a look, but traditional GIS platforms have a couple of major limitations that make it difficult to work with curbside regulation data.
GIS does not work well with temporal complexity
Curbside regulation layers are complex spatially. It’s very common for a single segment to have multiple rules that apply to it – e.g. a no parking zone for an entire block face, but with a taxi stand and courier delivery zone placed right in the middle.
GIS does not work well with non-tabular data sets
Working with data in tabular formats like CSVs and shapefiles is the bread and butter of traditional GIS. But curbside regulations are typically in JSON formats with more easily expandable data structures.
When dealing with curbside data JSON data structures are required to capture all of the detail related to curbside regulations – where they apply, what uses are allowed there, when they are in force, how they relate to other overlapping regulations, and more. These files can be converted to tabular structures to allow for backwards compatibility with legacy systems, but the resulting number of attributes can grow to become unwieldy to work with for areas with complex curbside regulations.
A better way
To help cities overcome the issues with traditional GIS platforms and leverage digitized curbside regulations we developed a set of simple tools purpose-built for managing curbside data. These cloud-based solutions are designed to be immediately familiar to anyone with prior GIS knowledge while being easy to use for non-technical folks as well.
The CurbIQ platform includes dynamic legends to accommodate new and unique types of regulations (curbside patios, anyone?) and automatically filters regulations to surface the highest priority regulation. CurbIQ tools also include filters to quickly view regulations for different times, days, and months. To understand how regulations change over a single day we’ve added a panel with a visual summary so it’s easy to see when restrictions change throughout the day on any street.
Recommended for you
Manage On-Street Parking to Optimize Off-Street Turnover
Unmanaged on-street parking can undermine off-street parking solutions. A curb management solution can address these problems by creating, managing, and sharing parking regulations in a visual and easy-to-navigate way.
The Resilient Curb: Future Proofing Through Curb Inventory Digitization
A future proof curb is designed and managed with the built-in capacity to quickly adapt to change. This can be supported by digitizing the curbside inventory.
How CurbIQ Enables Complete Street Transformations
The City of Toronto's ActiveTO Midtown Complete Street Pilot used CurbIQ to understand the existing curbside regulations along midtown corridors. This was a key first milestone for the project.